877-415-8342 | 419-678-2326 service@preferredcenter.com


As you can imagine, that day in July 2015 created a lot of claims.  It wasn’t pretty for anyone.  But it did bring with it one great blessing for Preferred Insurance Center.  It made us better, a lot better.

You see, we handled claims that day pretty much the same way we had been handling them for 15 years…which was ok…and  probably the same way they were handled by every other agency.  But Preferred Insurance Center isn’t here to be OK or like everyone else.  We expect to be the best, and that day, we weren’t.

So we looked at our processes and talked to our clients…and changed.

  • First we decided to call you twice as often to keep you better informed.
  • Then we created a system to automatically send you regular emails with any new information we received regarding your claim.
  • And then we did what everyone told us couldn’t be done!  We created openned up our system so you could see all our notes, emails, forms and estimates regarding your claim.  When you have a claim, we share everything we have with you.  If we make a mistake, or the company adjuster does, you’ll be able to see.  If we make a note, you’ll be able to read.  We figure if we are the best, we have nothing to hide, and we don’t

We think you’ll love our new claims process, and you can’t get it anywhere but Preferred Insurance Center


Real 24/7 Claims Service
Car accidents, bad weather, fires…they happen, and when they do, Preferred Insurance Center will be there.  Bad things don’t always happen between 9 and 5, so who do you call at 3:00 AM?  Below are Dan  and Roger’s cell phone numbers.
When you have an emergency, we have an emergency.




Of course, if it’s not an emergency, you have some other options.
You’ve had a car accident, now what?
  • First make sure everyone is OK. Call the police or 911, if necessary.
  • For the fastest service, call the claim number on your insurance card from the scene of the accident.
  • If you have a cell phone, take some pictures.
  • Gather vital information.
    • Describe exactly what happened in as much detail as possible.
    • Be sure to include where and when the accident happened.
    • Make of vehicles and license plate numbers.
    • Name and contact information for everyone involved.
    • Describe any injuries in detail, if possible.
    • What law enforcement agency responded and how to contact them.
You’ve had damage to your property, now what?
  • First, make sure everyone is OK. Call the police or 911, if necessary.
  • For the fastest service, call the claim number on your insurance card right away.
  • If you have a cell phone, take some pictures.
  • Describe exactly what happened in as much detail as possible.


If you have damaged property and need emergency repairs…
We strongly recommend you contact
Swartz Contracting
Your Complete Disaster Cleanup Solution
Of course, always call Preferred Insurance Center so we can tell you what to expect. (419) 678-2326
 Company Direct  Claims Phone#
 Auto Owners   888-252-4626
 Donegal  800-877-9006
 Liberty Mutual  866-255-5530
 Safeco   800-332-3226
 Travelers  800-252-4633
 Westfield  800-937-2663
 Everett Cash  888-717-8090
 Progressive  800-274-4499
Keystone Nat.  570-746-1515
 Water Restoration  Phone#
 Swartz Cntrng  800-462-1024
 Enyart Floor  419-678-8777
 Stanley Steem  419-586-4070
 Prof. Floor   419-678-2517
 Servicemaster  419-394-2369
 Reliable Floor  419-925-5555
 Carpet Clean  419-628-4431
 Fullenkamp   419-375-2155
 Rainbow  419-394-2787


Meet The Team
Community Involvement
Tell Us What You Think
What Is #PreferredMovement
We Love Your Referrals

At Preferred Insurance Center we do a lot of things right.

  • We give $10 to charity every time we give a quote.
  • We do your shopping for you. One call usually gets you quotes from 8 great companies.
  • We save people hundreds of dollars on their insurance.
  • You are our friends and neighbors and we expect you to call us at home after hours when you have a problem.