877-415-8342 | 419-678-2326 service@preferredcenter.com
You’re A Good Man Charlie Brown!

You’re A Good Man Charlie Brown!

The amazing Coldwater High School Drama club is doing another, just barely off Broadway production, and it’s an all-time favorite:

You’re A Good Man Charlie Brown

You can get a preview here, but to catch the whole show you need to go to the Coldwater High School Auditeria for one (or all 🙂 ) of the following shows!

Friday, April 28th – 7PM
Saturday, April 29th – 7PM
Sunday, April 30th – 2PM

Spring Fling Giveaway Winner

Spring Fling Giveaway Winner

We had an overwhelming response to our Spring Fling Giveaway! Thank you all so much who participated in the giveaway!

By liking, commenting and sharing the Facebook giveaway post, you were entered to win a $700 gift certificate to Borger’s Bicycles in Coldwater, Ohio. We would like to announce that the lucky winner of the $700 gift certificate is…

STEPHEN WINNER of Versailles, Ohio!!

Thanksgiving Day Giveaway Winner is…

Thanksgiving Day Giveaway Winner is…

BIG congratulations to Tamra Dues on being the winner of our Thanksgiving Day Giveaway!


Tamra won a KitchenAid Artisan mixer and KitchenAid glass bowl with attachments. Tamra commented in the Facebook contest that she was most thankful for her family. By doing so, she won a  KitchenAid baking sheet, KitchenAid cake pan and a KitchenAid cook book for a lucky family member of hers! She told us she was going to give these baking items to her sister Leah Bruns.

We want to thank everyone for participating in this contest! By the looks of it, we all have a LOT to be thankful for and we wish everyone a HAPPY THANKSGIVING! 🙂


Follow us on Facebook so you could be our next BIG winner!

Winner of the OSU v Michigan tickets : Dean & Lynne Huelsman

Winner of the OSU v Michigan tickets : Dean & Lynne Huelsman


As you most likely know by now, Preferred Insurance Center is sponsoring Craig Muhlenkamp & Susie Muhlenkamp in the Dancing With the Big Stars competition. This is a major fundraiser benefiting Big Brothers Big Sisters of Mercer/Auglaize County.

The 3nd Annual Dancing with the BIG Stars will be held this year with an exciting competition between dancers. On November 12, a group of well-known community members will test new skills with experienced dance partners as they dance for Big Brothers Big Sisters of Mercer, Auglaize, & Van Wert Counties at this year’s Dancing with the BIG Stars. This fundraiser is modeled after the long-running television series, Dancing with the Stars.

CLICK HERE if you would still like to donate to Big Brothers & Big Sisters!

Nine citizens from the Mercer, Auglaize, & Van Wert County area have been paired with local dancers from various studios throughout the area.

In efforts to help make this fundraiser a success for Big Brothers Big Sisters, we were giving away 2 OSU v. Michigan tickets for donating. For every $10 donated a person would receive 1 entry.

Yesterday we gave the phone call to Dean & Lynne Huelsman of Coldwater, Ohio, letting them know they were the lucky winners of the 2 OSU v. Michigan tickets! They were surprised and excited! Dean made the comment that going to a OSU v Michigan football game was always on his bucket list!



We want to give a HUGE thank you to all who have donated! Your generosity is greatly appreciated! Preferred Insurance has several team members that serve as Lunch Buddies for Big Brothers and Big Sisters and know how big of a difference the program is making in our community!

Back To School Giveaway | And the winner is….

Back To School Giveaway | And the winner is….

We would like to announce the winner of the Back to School Giveaway is ANITA HEMMELGARN of St. Henry, Ohio! She was the lucky one of over 1,000 shares and likes for the Facebook giveaway. The giveaway included: basket of school supplies, $100 Kohl’s gift card and a $100 Walmart gift card.


Anita also was one of many who gave a shout out to a teacher, for that teacher to win a $50 Kohls Gift Card. The teacher she acknowledged was Katie Hill, who teaches in Columbus.

We want to thank all of those who participated in the giveaway and especially all those teachers getting ready to teach this 2016-2017 school year!


YAY For the USA WINNER : Ashley Ahrens

YAY For the USA WINNER : Ashley Ahrens

What a great way to kick off the Fourth of July weekend by winning the YAY for the USA Giveaway!!

We would like to congratulate ASHLEY AHRENS, of Coldwater, Ohio on winning our giveaway!

Earlier this morning Amanda and Chris had the pleasure of surprising Ashley at her home with the exciting news!


The Winner of the Yeti Tumbler is: Jeff Behm, of Coldwater . Who was saluted by Scott Behm.

Jeff Behm

Winner of the YETI Tumbler: Jeff Behm, who was saluted by Scott Behm!

We would like to thank everyone who participated in the contest. Our office was particularly overwhelmed by the shout outs to all the Veterans made in the comment post! Many loved ones that have or are currently serving this wonderful country for us!

If you have a suggestion for our next giveaway, please leave a comment! We’d love to hear from you!!

St Henry Garage Sale 2016!

For best viewing, rotate your phone.

You’ll never believe who just won $1,000!!!

You’ll never believe who just won $1,000!!!


The much anticipated news is HERE! As you may know, we have been asking people for referrals in exchange for an entry to win $1,000! But the deal was much sweeter than it appeared. When you referred a friend, both you and your friend were entered to win $1,000 EACH!

Unbelievable, huh? Here is the story behind the 2015 Referral Drawing Winners:


One of our Superb Service Specialist, Kathy Riethman, had the pleasure of speaking with Larry Langston one day. Kathy wanted Larry to have a chance to win $1,000 and the opportunity to save any of Larry’s friends/family money by letting Preferred Insurance quoting their insurance. So she asked if Larry had any friends or family to refer…


You see, Larry is a very thoughtful father. Larry referred his son Steve Langston. Larry was only looking out for Steve’s best interests by referring his son to Preferred Insurance AND for an entry to win $1,000. BUT, before we could make an entry for both Larry and Steve…


We politely gave Steve a call and by him picking up the phone they were both entered into the $1,000 Referral Drawing. Please note: this was a NO OBLIGATION phone call, Steve just simply had to pick up the phone to be entered.


That phone call that Steve took ended up being a $1,000 call! The entry of Larry Langston referring Steve Langston was our 2015 Referral Drawing Winner!


The fun is not over!

With popular demand, we decided to start up the 2016 Referral Drawing. Click below to start referring your friends and family and a chance to win $1,000 each!

Remember: for every referral you gain an entry to win the $1,000. You refer 5 friends = you get 5 entries!

Refer A Friend!

We have a winner! | Hueston Woods Lodge Giveaway

We have a winner! | Hueston Woods Lodge Giveaway

hueston-woods-winnerWe would like to announce that the winner of the Hueston Woods Lodge Giveaway is Elizabeth Bergman, of Maria Stein, Ohio!

Hueston Woods Lodge and Conference Center is a spacious, comfortable retreat offering all the amenities of home. Located in an area rich in history and surrounded by natural splendor just 5 miles from Miami University.

Congratulations Elizabeth and enjoy your trip! Thanks everyone for participating!