Insurance With Purpose

Making a Difference in Ohio and Indiana for More Than 100 Years

Doing More by Doing Good

Our team is made up of 100% real people who are ready to help you with whatever your insurance needs are. And we also do things a little differently than some insurance companies. We sell insurance so we can make a positive impact in our community through our Quotes4Causes program, service days, and more.



"The staff at Preferred Insurance are so thorough and helpful. They call and follow up on claims and work hard to serve your insurance needs. I highly recommend anyone looking for an insurance agency to consider Preferred."

Carrie W.

"Preferred Insurance has done a great job for me since I trusted them with my business six years ago. [They] provided me with a very high level of customer service that you don't see in the business world today. I would recommend them to everyone."

Bryan K.

"We are proud to say that we are clients of Preferred Insurance. They have worked hard to make sure we are getting the best deals in insurance. Kelly at Preferred shopped around for us and saved us several hundred dollars. They are available to talk to and answer questions whenever we have needed advice or help. We are not only satisfied with our service but appreciate all they do in the community. I would recommend them to anyone looking for insurance."

Rick Z.

"My wife is from Coldwater. We have been married for over 29 years and have used Preferred Insurance Center for our, and now our adult children's, insurance needs for this entire period. They do a great job! Very efficient, knowledgeable, polite, and always willing to help in any way they can. Highly recommend!!!!!!!!!"

David P.